The Presence of Absence & the Absence of Presence: War & The Holocaust

by K Shabi PUBLISHED 31 May 2014

What is the presence of absence and the absence of presence? Philosopher Jacques Derrida's metaphysical concept of the absence of presence is by definition inconceivable and difficult to trace. Sometimes we can begin to find meaning in the incomprehensible when we view it through our own lens of personal experience. At the end of the Holocaust documentary Engineering Evil (2011), Michael Berenbaum of the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum shares a meaningful personal account and his own take on Derrida's postmodern deconstructionist philosophy, giving deep new meaning to the phrase "the absence of presence."

Death & the Holocaust: The Presence of Absence and the Absence of Presence

"Let me talk deeply, personally, with where I first came face to face with the presence of absence. My father died in 1990. [...] The first Friday night, we sat down to dinner... My father's chair was empty. We literally couldn't eat until my mother said, "You sit in your father's chair." Because my father's absence loomed larger than anybody present.

You come to Sobibor and it's empty. You can barely imagine or fathom what is there. But that absence shows a presence. The ghosts are there, the images are there, the souls are there, the evil is there, and the magnitude of what happened is there, even if it's unseen.

If you look today at the sites of destruction, there is a paradox. It is the presence of absence and the absence of presence. You see something, and what you see is also what's not there. And if you don't see something, then that looms present for you in an extraordinary way." Michael Berenbaum, Engineering Evil (2011)

What is the meaning of the absence of presence? For Berenbaum, the meaning of the presence of absence becomes clear only after the experience of great personal loss, in his case with the death of his father. As Berenbaum states, "My father's absence loomed larger than anybody present." Using his own experience of grief as a jumping-off point, Berenbaum begins with a personal interpretation of the meaning of the presence of absence, but then moves beyond the personal by relating that experience to his visit to the site of the former death camp Sobibor.

Berenbaum calls Sobibor a "site of destruction," a place of death and war, of collective trauma: what we can interpret as a place of such grief, devastation and loss that transcends beyond the personal, to a social and cultural level. Though abandoned and seemingly deserted, for Berenbaum the grounds of Sobibor are full of lost ghosts, images, and souls. For Berenbaum, Sobibor and places like it - sites of collective trauma - are overflowing with the presence of absence and the absence of presence, leaving visitors filled with the same empty feeling he felt staring at his father's empty chair at the dinner table.

The Presence of Absence & the Absence of Presence: War & The Holocaust
The Pianist (2002)

The Pianist and the Meaning of the Absence of Presence

Michael Berenbaum's interpretation of "the presence of absence" adds another layer of meaning to the final scene of Roman Polanski's World War II Holocaust film The Pianist (2002). In the movie's closing sequence, shortly after the end of the war Władysław Szpilman accompanies his friend to the site of a POW camp he passed through just a few weeks earlier. Even though only a short period of time has passed, no trace of the former POW camp remains. The fences and walls once lined with prisoners have all been hauled away, dismantled and removed, with only a natural and nondescript blanket of green grass remaining. In disbelief Szpilman's friend murmurs, "It was here, I'm certain of it," but any outward evidence to support his claim has disappeared, mysteriously or not.

"It was here, I'm certain of it." The Pianist (2002)

PJ Harvey's "On Battleship Hill" Meaning: Presence of Absence & the Trace of Thyme

PJ Harvey also seems to touch on Derrida's concept of the absence of presence and the presence of absence in the Let England Shake track "On Battleship Hill." Visiting another European site of destruction left behind after a World War, Harvey tours the "caved in trenches" of a deserted battlefield now overgrown with wild thyme.

"On Battleship Hill's caved in trenches, a hateful feeling still lingers.
Even now, 80 years later... Cruel nature. Cruel, cruel nature.

The land returns to how it's always been. Thyme carried on the wind." PJ Harvey, "On Battleship Hill"

The thyme here echoes Berenbaum's sentiment that if you sense something, you also sense "what's not there." A strongly scented herb, traditionally thyme has been used to cover up and clear out the smell of death and decay. As travel writer Ross Davies writes, during World War I thyme was even thrown in the trenches of Gallipoli, what Davies calls a "wild and lonely place" to visit even today. In PJ Harvey's "On Battleship Hill" song lyrics, the herb's fragrant presence masks and distracts from the true essence of the scene, a No Man's Land of many casualties and deaths.

Absence of Presence Meaning: Collective Trauma & Personal and Cultural Significance

What is the presence of absence? Sites of destruction and collective trauma are haunting specifically because as humans we feel as though there should be some eternal sign (or even just a trace) left behind to mark the scene with all the loss and pain that has transpired there. Instead, it seems as though sites of destruction and war quickly revert back to an unheimlich wild state of nature, therein perhaps revealing their true identities more so than disguising themselves.

filed under: movies, culture

Paint it Black Meaning: Rolling Stones' Song Lyrics Interpretation & Analysis

What is the meaning of the song "Paint it Black" by the Rolling Stones? An interpretation and analysis of the song lyrics reveals the importance of the Vietnam War in "Paint it Black."

Eyes Wide Shut Meaning: Plague Doctor Masks & Stanley Kubrick's Movie

What is the meaning of Stanley Kubrick's 1999 movie Eyes Wide Shut? Plague doctor masks and the infamous party scene unlock the film's many hidden meanings.

Tiger in a Tropical Storm: Life of Pi Meaning, Analysis, Movie Symbolism

Was Henri Rousseau's painting A Tiger in a Tropical Storm one of the influences of the novel and movie Life of Pi? An analysis of Rousseau's painting reveals the hidden meaning and symbolism of Life of Pi.

Guernica Meaning: Analysis & Interpretation of Painting by Pablo Picasso

What is the meaning of Guernica, the 1937 mural by Pablo Picasso? Spain and bullfighting influence the meaning of this famous anti war painting.

Symbols of Death in Art Analysis: Ingmar Bergman Seventh Seal Meaning

An analysis of The Seventh Seal reveals the meaning of art history in the film, with Ingmar Bergman using multiple symbols of death in art popular during the Black Death.

The Movie Inside Llewyn Davis & Bob Dylan: Who Is Llewyn Davis?

Who is Llewyn Davis? There are similarities between the fictional title character of the Coen Brothers' movie Inside Llewyn Davis and Bob Dylan. Is Llewyn Davis Bob Dylan?

Siouxsie & The Banshees Metal Postcard, John Heartfield Photomontage Art

What does Siouxsie and the Banshees' post punk music have to do with anti Nazi Berlin Dada art? Everything!

What is the meaning?

Garden of Earthly Delights: Analysis & Meaning of the Bosch Painting

What is the meaning of the famous painting Garden of Earthly Delights by artist Hieronymus Bosch? Can we really find modern significance in any interpretation of this mysterious work of art?

Paint it Black Meaning: Rolling Stones' Song Lyrics Interpretation & Analysis

What is the meaning of the song "Paint it Black" by the Rolling Stones? An interpretation and analysis of the song lyrics reveals the importance of the Vietnam War in "Paint it Black."

Dreamcatcher Meaning: History, Legend & Origins of Dream Catchers

What is the meaning and history of dream catchers? What are the origins, legend and story behind the dreamcatcher?

Meaning of Radiohead's Kid A "Bear" Art: Inspired by Charles Burchfield?

What is the meaning of the Radiohead bear art? The Kid A bear logo has become a symbol of Radiohead itself and may have been inspired by American artist Charles Burchfield.

Game of Thrones: Hall of Faces

Why did Jon Snow die? Find out why your favorite Game of Thrones characters died in the Hall of Faces.

Mad Men Meaning: The Ending of the Mad Men Series Finale

What did the end of the AMC TV series Mad Men mean? Why does Don Draper smile? Who made the Coke ad? What is the true meaning of the Mad Men Season 7 finale ending?